12-05-2014

It Ain't Gonna Rain No Mo' (1923)

Traditional
O: Will Lyle 1889 on Edison
C: Wendel Hall 1923 on Edison







I found this about the Will Lyle recording. I don't have the book so this print from Google:

America's Best Loved Country Songs: An Encyclopedia of ...
books.google.nl/books?isbn=0786449942 - Vertaal deze pagina
Dorothy Horstman, ‎Fritzi Horstman - 2010 - ‎Music
An Encyclopedia of More Than 3,000 Classics Through the 1980s Dorothy ... Recording Found: Will Lyle (Edison) 1889 (as “Ain't Going to Rain No More”).


From Wikipedia: 

"It Ain't Gonna Rain No Mo'" is the title of a song that is entirely the creation of the "Red-Headed Music Maker", guitarist and vocalist Wendell Woods Hall (1896–1969).. Hall's 1923 recording of the song was popular in Britain and sold in excess of two million copies.[1] Additionally, it scored 20 weeks on the U.S. charts, six at number one.[2]

Many antecedents exist from the 19th century. By the 1920s many variants were already extant in popular culture. Carl Sandburg suggests that the song goes back at least to the 1870s and includes verses in his "American Songbag (published 1927). This song is an excellent example of the folk tradition of transmission with local variants. Mr. Hall most likely codified what already existed and added original verses.





Apparently this was written without the knowledge of the Will Lyle recording.

We are most familiar with the Victor recording, but Wendell Halle recorded it also on 4 oktober 1923 for Edison as part of a recording of "I'm a Red Headed Music Maker".
This recording sounds a little bit like a part of the Wendell Hall Show. Everything is in the dl file.

                                                                                                                   
1923 12 Okt - Wendell Hall - It Ain't Gonna Rain No Mo'.
1923 4 Okt - Wendell Hall - I'm a Red Headed Music Maker.
1923 4 Okt - Wendell Hall - It Ain't Gonna Rain No Mo'.
1924 - Billy Jones & Ernest Hare - It Ain't Gonna Rain No More.
1924 - Billy Murray & Ed Smalle - It Ain't Gonna Rain No Mo'.
1925 - DeFord Bailey - Ain't Gonna Rain No More.
1925 - Savoy Orpheans - It Ain't Gonna Rain No Mo'.
1929 - Gid Tanner & His Skillet Lickers - It Ain't Gonna Rain No More.
1929 - Zydeco Skillet Lickers - 1t Ain't Gonna Rain No Mo.
1934 - Ain't Gonna Rain No More - Eight Unidentified Girls.
1939 - It Ain't Gonna Rain No Mo' - Hank Penny & His Radio Cowboys
1947 - Vera Hall - Ain't Gonna Rain No More.
1951 - Ewan Maccoll - Ain't Gonna Rain No More.
1951 - Nappy Lamare and His Strawhat Strutters - It Ain't Gonna Rain No Mo'
1957 - Fiddlin' Arthur Smith & Earl Scruggs - Ain't Gonna Rain No More.
1962 - Gus Cannon - Ain't Gonna Rain No More.
1965 - The Kentucky Colonels - It Ain't Gonna Rain No More.
1977 - Disneyland Children's Sing-Along Chorus & Larry Groce - It Ain't Gonna Rain No More
1977 - John Snipes - Ain't Gonna Rain No More
1978 - Tom Waits - It Ain't Gonna Rain No More.
1979 - Jamie Alson - Ain't Gonna Rain No More.
1999 - Mance Lipscomb - It Ain't Gonna Rain No More.
2003 - Doug Van Gundy & Paul Gartner - Ain't Gonna Rain No More.
2005 - Clint Howard, Fred Price & Their Sons - Ain't Gonna Rain No More.
2007 - Arthur Kuykendall - Ain't Gonna Rain No More.
2008 - Tom Turner - Ain't Gonna Rain No More.mp3







You can get them if you really want

4 opmerkingen:

Joop zei

Dag Roel,

Ik ben ik ook al eens achterheen geweest.
Ik heb een nog oudere uitvoering van Wendel Hall op het Gennett-label (#5271), opgenomen op 1 Oktober 1923.

Joop groet

Joop zei


vergat ik de link te geven waar je de oudere kunt halen

http://www.45worlds.com/78rpm/record/5271

PS die van Will Lyle, bestaat die opname wel ?
Want het schijnt dat die Lyle ook de eerste "Jingle Bells" heeft opgenomen in 1889, maar daar zijn geen opnamen meer van.

Joop groet

SnowyBowie zei

Of de uitvoering van Will Lyle nog bestaat Joop. weet ik niet. Maar hij heeft het nummer opgenomen en wie weet....

SnowyBowie zei

Ik denk dat ik bovengenoemd boek maar ga bestellen